F.P. Blair Lee ’63: A three-sport star in football, basketball, and track & field. His greatest sports glory at Prep came in football, where he was a 3-year starter, 2-time All-IAC, and first-team All-Met. He played for Coach Jim Fegan’s first two teams, including the 1962 squad, which was the first undefeated football team in school history and for which he was co-captain. In addition to making All-Met that year, he was named a scholar-athlete award winner by the National Football Foundation. Vice President of the Yard at Prep, he attended Princeton University, where he was a starter on an undefeated Ivy League championship team.
Harry J. Aburrow ’65: A three-sport star in football, basketball, and golf. He was captain of the basketball and golf teams his senior year and, together with his twin brother, Paul, terrorized opposing teams from the football backfield and the basketball back court. He was a 2-time All-Met, 2-time All-Catholic, and 2-time All-IAC selection in football; a 2-time All-Catholic and 2-time All-IAC in basketball; and a 2-time All-IAC in golf.
J. Patrick DiNenna ’75: A four-sport star in football, basketball, baseball, and track & field. His biggest impact was on the football field, where he started on both offense and defense for three years, leading Prep to a 20-4-2 record in that span. He gained the most attention at middle guard, where he was All-Met in 1974 and was named High School Defensive Player of the Year for the DC area.
William E. Oshodin ’87: His story is one of the most remarkable in school history. A boarding student from Nigeria, he had never played football before attending Prep and then only played varsity his senior year, when his ferocious play at defensive end helped anchor the Hall of Fame 1986 team, which allowed just 6 defensive points all season. More well-known by colleges for his lacrosse skills, he attended Villanova to play that sport. When Villanova revived football, he joined the team and was eventually signed by the Denver Broncos, from whom he became a starter at defensive end and enjoyed the longest NFL career of any Prep alumnus.
Frederick L. Shreves III ’89: A three-sport star in football, basketball, and golf, he is one of a handful of the greatest golfers in school history, making first-team All-Met all four years of his career. Winner of the Frank Emmet Schoolboy his senior year, he continued his golf career at the University of Virginia. In football, he was an outstanding receiver and the first-team All-Met kicker for Prep’s 1988 team, which was part of a 32-game unbeaten streak, one of the longest in DC-area history.
Sacha Fraiture ’92: A four-year superstar in both soccer and lacrosse, he anchored an undefeated soccer team that scored 99 goals while compiling a 15-0 record in 1991. He made first-team All-Met as lacrosse goalie in 1992, helping establish Prep as a power only a few years after the inception of the program. Along with his father, Prep soccer Coach Guy Fraiture, he completes the first GP Hall of Fame father-son combination.
1973-74-75 Golf Teams: Coached by the late Gus Coupe, this 3-year run by the golf team was truly dominating. The team won the IAC and the Metro Championship all 3 years. In fact, this squad lost just one match in those 3 years, to Ireton, and then avenged it en route to winning the Eastern Interscholastic Championship. The members of those 3 teams: W. Lawrence Greif ’73; Michael V. Agostinelli ’74; E. Larry Sanders III ’74; Michael J. Bittman ’75; Gordon W. Daisley ’75; Daniel Q. Greif ’75; Charles C. Habliston ’75; R. Edward Offterdinger ’75; J. Eugene Sullivan ’75; W. Edward Tydings ’75; Paul T. Ryan ’76.
Robert C. Barry, Golf Coach, 1984-Present: His teams have won 18 IAC championships, 8 Metro titles, and 6 Eastern Interscholastic championships. Of his individual golfers, 46 have made All-IAC (including 6 who made it all 4 years); 21 have made All-Met (including 4 who made it all 4 years); 12 have won the individual IAC crown (including 2 who won it 3 times); and 7 have won the individual Metro crown (including 1 who won it all 4 years). An English teacher at Prep since 1971, he also served a stint as the school’s Headmaster.